Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Congress Shows Their Hand Against FCC Net Neutrality
As CNET blogger, Larry Downes, put it, "Action follows hearings. The hearings weren't simply for show." Downes, who was called to testify on
Capital Hill last week regarding the FCC's recent Net Neutrality regulations, suspects we will see the FCC's net neutrality regulations overturned by the now-republican congress.
Why? In short, because there was no need for it. Congress asked the FCC to demonstrate that a crisis of power was stirring in the world of broadband providers, one that would require government intervention in order to keep the market stability, and according to one congressman, they could not. "We held a hearing today in which we gave the commissioners of the FCC one more opportunity to provide sufficient evidence of a crisis that warrants government intervention. They failed." said committee chairman, Fred Upton. "The controversial Internet regulations stifle innovation, investment and jobs. A federal bureaucracy should not be picking winners and losers."
The proponents of the FCC's ruling are not left without answer, however, as many have pointed out that one simple reason for overturning the ruling in the first place is that protection already exists for the broadband market. Existing antitrust laws already in place can be, and indeed have been, used to keep the t-com titans in check.
At stake for the FCC is the exclusive power to regulate the businesses in its own industry. Antitrust laws are FTC-enforced and regulate every industry from software to baking powder. By putting forth regulations specific to the Internet and how it is used in commerce, the FCC is flexing a muscle that says, "Our arena is different." And, I'm not sure I disagree. The questions over how data is managed across nationwide networks, down to the 1's and 0's of switching, packets, and sniffing that few people in the industry understand, let alone those outside, might just be too much for a non-specialized agency to handle.
Nevertheless, congress is saying, the FCC can offer their expertise when needed for a ruling on existing laws. Indications appear clear that by this Spring, net neutrality will be squashed, if not directly, effectively though budget diversions and other measures at congress' disposal. Those in favor of net neutrality will have to, at least for now, rely on the existing laws our nation has put forth to protect the free market.
Labels: Broadband, FCC, Net Neutrality, Telecommunication
posted by Unknown at 4:51 AM
Link to this Article
0 Comments
###
Tuesday, January 25, 2011
Verizon Going to Court over Net Neutrality
Verizon will be going to court with the FCC over Net Neutrality regulations. Well, at least they hope so. They've filed in the US Appeals Court in the Washington D.C. circuit where they know that a ISP-friendly ruling was made just a few months back. Whether a hearing will be granted remains to be seen, but this is the first major court action that an ISP has taken against the FCC's new step in internet regulation.
Verizon asserted in its appeal that the rules are in excess of the F.C.C.’s statutory authority. In a statement, the company said, “We are deeply concerned by the F.C.C.’s assertion of broad authority for sweeping new regulation of broadband networks and the Internet itself. We believe this assertion of authority goes well beyond any authority provided by Congress, and creates uncertainty for the communications industry, innovators, investors and consumers.”
In short: does the FCC have the authority to dictate what an ISP can filter on it's services? Or, stated positively, does the FCC have the authority to mandate ISP's to carry all content (within reason) on it's services?
Well, the question comes to this: what might an ISP want to filter? Verizon, for instance, if left unregulated could conceivably block AT&T's website. Nasty competition, right? But is that what Verizon is going to court over?
I don't believe so (and I doubt Verizon would argue it publicly if it were the case). But what about alternatives--not direct competitors--such as Hulu.com or Skype. These services offer an alternative to Verizon's voice and television services. However, they rely on Verizon's broadband service for delivery.
I was quick to argue once, as I'm sure you may be now, "Yes, but the customer is paying for that broadband, so what's the problem?" The problem, in Verizon's view, is that Hulu.com and Skype consume such a large portion of bandwidth proportionally to other ordinary internet usage that they can affect Verizon's ability to deliver quality service to all subscribers sharing a trunk. Raising the cost for all customers in order to fund the enhancements required doesn't hardly seem fair to all consumers, and especially dangerous for Verizon who could risk losing customers over rate hikes.
Oh wait, there's an easy solution: what if Verizon only charged extra for the users who access Hulu.com or Skype, or the like? And therein lies the problem. As stated, the FCC's current regulations on Net Neutrality would prevent Verizon from legally filtering the content to determine which internet-enabled services one of their subscribers was using.
Is there an easy answer? No. Do I want net neutrality? In theory, I believe so. Do I feel sympathetic to the ISP's market-driven and profit-concerning problems? I do.
What would you have companies like Verizon do?
Labels: Broadband, ISP, Net Neutrality, Verizon
posted by Unknown at 6:20 AM
Link to this Article
0 Comments
###
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Net Neutrality: A Conversation with a Local ISP
I was at a dinner party recently with some friends from our church. Typically, the riveting details of FCC regulation over telecom and Internet usage is not a topic of conversation. But, conspiracy theories are always fun to throw out. To get a reaction, I mentioned, "Did you hear that cable companies can scan your packets and know what you're downloading?" And, boy did I get a reaction.
I had only met Andy a few times. I didn't know his occupation, only that he liked to work with the kids in our youth group. So, when he innocently asked, "Why would they do that?" I answered as if he was unaware of the issue. "Let's say a company provides cable TV and Internet," I told him, "They can see if you're streaming video and deprioritize those packets because it competes with their TV product." A simple enough proposition (not to mention conspiracy theory), I thought.
I had no idea that Andy was a QA engineer for a local cable company.
"We don't do that." He answered. Uh oh. Time to shut up, I thought to myself.
He went on to explain: we charge for Internet. We charge for TV. If you want to stream TV over the Internet, fine. You'll need more bandwidth. You won't be able to get the performance you want without upgrading your Internet. And then he explained it perfectly: "One way or the other, that data has to make it to your house. You can pay for the bandwidth to haul it in, or you can subscribe to our TV signal. Either way is fine with us."
Just one person's opinion, for sure, but I found it interesting to hear that the world of ISP's is not united in their cry on Capitol Hill. As we continued talking about competitors like Skype, Vonage, Hulu.com and the like, he was unilaterally unconcerned.
So, is
Net Neutrality really that great of a controversy, or simply a loud minority causing a stir?
Labels: Internet, ISP, Net Neutrality
posted by Unknown at 5:39 AM
Link to this Article
0 Comments
###
Tuesday, December 21, 2010
Big Day for Net-Neutrality in Washington
It's here: the day that content-providers dreaded and that ISP's thought would never come. The FCC is expected to approve a new set of regulations affecting what's known as "
Net-Neutrality" -- the idea that all content on the internet is treated equally. The regulations protect the limited bandwidth of wireless providers by enabling more granular control of their packets, while still protecting the freedom to compete among wireline providers.
Broadband providers servicing customers through terrestrial network will be, for all intents and purposes, required to uphold net neutrality. Under the new rules, fixed-line providers will not be able to charge content-providers such as Skype,YouTube, or any other high-bandwidth providers, for preferential delivery of their packets. Nor can they inhibit their packets. In particular, fixed-line providers cannot de-prioritize traffic from their competitors.
Fixed Wireless Broadband providers on the other hand have a little more lenience. Under the new rules, wireless broadband providers will be permitted to charge additional fees to content providers for faster delivery to the broadband consumer, or block the service altogether. The competitive restriction remains, however, disallowing any broadband provider--wireless or otherwise--from de-prioritizing or blocking content from their competitors.
What does this mean for the average Internet consumer? Costs for broadband services may stabilize or even drop as broadband providers find new revenue through charging the most bandwidth-intensive companies for delivery of their packets. However, it remains to be seen whether those same costs will pass along to the consumer in other forms via fees levied by services such as Hulu or YouTube for accessing it's content.
Will this change the user experience of the Internet forever? Will the Gen-X'ers "back in my day" stories be about the old internet told to starry-eyed kids who can hardly believe life really used to work that way?
Labels: FCC, Fixed Wireless Broadband, Net Neutrality
posted by Unknown at 5:35 AM
Link to this Article
0 Comments
###
Tuesday, August 10, 2010
What is Net Neutrality?
A lot of talk has been taking place recently over an issue of Net Neutrality. Typically, you'll hear this term slung around in accusatory tone from one ISP to a larger, or from an advocacy group against the super-giants,
Verizon and Google to name a few. It's a debate that, at it's core, echos the tradition in American spirit that empowers the "little guy" in his never-ending fight against the tyrannical "big guy."
Ok, that may be an oversimplification, but if you read from the advocate's perspective, that's the tale you'll likely hear. Of course, from the other side of the table, the non-regulated, invisible hand, free market capitalist flag is flying high. So which is it? Tyrants vs Serfs? Socialists vs Capitalists? I'm torn... I'm a capitalist, and a "little guy," where do I fall?
To understand
Net Neutrality, you must first understand how the Internet works... no, not the technical side of it, the commercial side. The side the makes (and costs) money. You see, the Internet is not some public infrastructure, owned and provided by the Government to the People as a tenet of citizenship and utility for daily life. It's a product, developed at a cost, and provided for a fee.
The question, then, is whether these intrepid companies who have built, acquired, or otherwise come to own (hence: control) said infrastructure at their own expense have the right to then control and prioritize, or even censor, the traffic which it carries. Depending on your bias, you may be quick to jump to a seemingly obvious conclusion. The independent spirit says, "yes, it's theirs, they can do as they wish." But the guardian of rights begins to question, "who gets left out, and why?"
Opponents of Net Neutrality argue from a posture of territorial rights. The ISP's and telecom companies who own the assets which power this beast we call the Internet certainly should have rights to control it's use. In order to ensure the profit that they absolutely require in order to sustain this infrastructure we've come to know, love, and depend on, they need some level of control.
What control would they place, you may ask? Well, de-prioritizing certain networks or other providers, for starters--those who might be competitors. Or, it's conceivable (and has even been accused) that certain content--websites, videos, ads, etc.--which promote the competition or any cause contrary to the profit-seeking purposes of the ISP. This begins to cross into censorship, control of information, and (ironically) a threat to the notion of free market and free speech.
Enter the opposing side. Now you see how the debate swirls. What, if any, control imposed by such infrastructure-backing corporations would be too much? Where is the line? How "neutral" do we need to be in order to be "fair?" And, of course, the ultimate question is: who, then should decide and enforce such a set of rules?
As I've said, I'm torn. I can argue fervently in either camp. What do you think?
Labels: "Internet infrastructure", Google, Internet, ISP, Net Neutrality, Telecommunication, Verizon
posted by Unknown at 7:58 AM
Link to this Article
0 Comments
###